Democracy Dies in Darkness

Period products are tested with saline. A study found many underperform.

Testing found that menstrual discs typically carried the most blood and menstrual underwear usually soaked up the least when also compared with pads, tampons and menstrual cups.

September 20, 2023 at 11:39 a.m. EDT
(Illustration by Elizabeth von Oehsen/The Washington Post; iStock)
5 min

A new study found that many period products may be less absorbent than advertised. The reason: Laboratory testing methods fail to mimic the experience of real periods.

Researchers from Oregon Health & Science University began studying the issue when they noticed more of their patients using menstrual cups. But it was difficult to compare their experiences with those of people who used other period products, because most measures of normal or heavy menstrual bleeding are based on how many pads or tampons are needed.